Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Dead Leaves and Dry Bones!

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Dead Leaves and Dry Bones!

    I like this part the best:

    Despite their degrees, résumés and pretensions, the Establishment is no longer made up of "policy" types. Most of its members are placemen. Their expertise is in becoming and remaining members of the Establishment.

    Dead Leaves and Dry Bones
    by William S. Lind

    Earlier this week, I enjoyed the somewhat odd experience of speaking to the Washington chapter of the Council on Foreign Relations. I say "odd" because my own views on foreign affairs are anti-Establishment, while the CFR is the holy of holies of the Establishment elite. To aspiring young Establishmentarians, membership in the CFR is a Holy Grail, the equivalent of joining the Praetorians in Imperial Rome or, among the Masons, achieving the rank of High Wingwang or perhaps even Exalted Grand Wazoo.

    I was there as part of a panel on Fourth Generation war. The Establishment would prefer not to notice the Fourth Generation, but Fourth Generation war has fastened its fangs firmly into the Establishment’s backside in Iraq, Afghanistan and elsewhere, so "attention must be paid." Sometimes that means inviting us anti-Establishment types and hoping we don’t break too much of the crockery.

    The other panelists were two retired Army officers, both of whom have written some good things on Third and Fourth Generation war, and a retired Marine Corps general who served as moderator. One panelist noted the degree to which we remain stuck in the Second Generation, especially in what is taught in the various armed forces schools and staff colleges. Another took the neo-con line, predicting a "coming American century," which is about as likely as a coming Austro-Hungarian century. Surprisingly, we all agreed on one point: however good the American military may be from the battalion level down, what goes on above that level doesn’t make much sense. One panelist hit the pig right on the snout on the Air Force’s F-22 fighter; the only way we will ever be able to use it is if we first give some to whoever is fighting us.

    But the most significant aspect of the session was not what any of the panelists said. It was the utter inability of the audience, distinguished members of the Council on Foreign Relations, to understand any of it. They were as bewildered as the Gadarene swine.

    The problem was two-fold. First, the heart of Fourth Generation war is a crisis of legitimacy of the state, and these people are the state. They are the "policy elite," the people who influence or even decide what hornet’s nests we will next stick our nose into around the globe. Us, not legitimate? Mais monsieur, le état c’est nous! Who could possibly doubt our right to rule? When I suggested folks like Hispanic gang members in L.A. and factory workers in Cleveland whose jobs they are helping outsource to China and India, I got blank looks. As Martin van Creveld said to me one day in my Washington office, "Everybody sees it except the people in the capital cities." The CFR is Exhibit A.

    The second reason is yet more fundamental. Despite their degrees, résumés and pretensions, the Establishment is no longer made up of "policy" types. Most of its members are placemen. Their expertise is in becoming and remaining members of the Establishment. Their reality is court politics, not the outside reality of a Fourth Generation world or any other kind of world. When that world intrudes, as it did in the panelists’ remarks, the proper response is to close the shutters on the windows of Versailles.

    The CFR had generously allowed me to bring a guest with me into its august precincts, a young Marine major who is doing some excellent work on how to fight Fourth Generation opponents. As we walked to the car, I said to him, "John, the next time you’re on an amphib off somebody’s coast, waiting for the order to go in, remember that these are the kind of people who will be making the decision."

    "From that standpoint, I sort of wish I had not come tonight," was his reply.

    There is nothing left of the vaunted Council on Foreign Relations, or of the Establishment it represents, but dead leaves and dry bones.

    February 28, 2004

    William Lind [send him mail] is Director of the Center for Cultural Conservatism at the Free Congress Foundation

  • #2
    Some help King should have provided before posting such an obscure post.

    The things that will destroy America are prosperity-at-any-price, peace-at-any-price, safety-first instead of duty-first, the love of soft living, and the get-rich-quick theory of life. -TR

    OFFICIAL LOUNGE SPONSOR OF NEW YORK CITY, TEDDY ROOSEVELT AND THE MARYLAND TERRAPINS

    Madyaks2 Thought Of The Day: I'm just as dumb as madyaks1.

    Comment


    • #3
      >>Despite their degrees, résumés and pretensions, the Establishment is no longer made up of "policy" types. Most of its members are placemen. Their expertise is in becoming and remaining members of the Establishment.<<

      In other words, careerist bureaucrats.
      And, frankly, it has never occured to me that "winning" a debate is important, or that I should be hurt when someone like Airshark or kah, among others (for whom winning a pseudo debate or declaring intellectual superiority over invisible others is obviously very important) ridicule me.

      -The Artist formerly known as King in KC

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by lasvegasreb@Feb 29 2004, 09:05 PM
        Some help King should have provided before posting such an obscure post.

        Good contribution, reb.

        The Lounge ALWAYS delivers.

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by Damtoft@Feb 29 2004, 09:06 PM
          >>Despite their degrees, résumés and pretensions, the Establishment is no longer made up of "policy" types. Most of its members are placemen. Their expertise is in becoming and remaining members of the Establishment.<<

          In other words, careerist bureaucrats.
          John:

          I really like that word "placemen" and his description of their expertise.

          I will no doubt shamelessly steal his lines.

          Comment


          • #6
            So basically these guys are just into keeping a paycheck coming. Dealing with reality means virtually nothing.

            I suspected this all along.

            Nice post.
            Turning the other cheek is better than burying the other body.

            Official Sport Lounge Sponsor of Rhode Island - Quincy Jones - Yadier Molina who knows no fear.
            God is stronger and the problem knows it.

            2017 BOTB bracket

            Comment


            • #7
              King,

              Bill Lind had one of the more fabulous essays on what has actually happened to western civilization a few years ago.

              (This actually ties in with Woodrow Wilson from the other thread)

              He characterized the "post-American civil war" period as one of huge technical progress and unlimited optimism. Technology roared ahead and no problem seemed unsolvable to the western elite classes.

              Certainly, some inequality persisted, but technology held the promise of utopian peace breaking out, no more hungry people, rising wages and incomes, limitless boundaries. In fact, the success was so rapid and so heady that the elites broke out their marxist texts and dreamed of planning utopia.

              (Anyone thinking this sounds like the Tower of Babel story from the Bible gets an A++)

              Anyway, WWI started as an assassination in the Balkans and eventually the conflagration engulfed the entire continent.

              The elites watched (in horror) as a generation of their young men were sacrificed with the very technology (the German machine gun in particular) that had given them such hope.

              In the words of Bernie Miklasz, this event "rocked their world".

              From that point forward, they've largely been cutting deals to secure their own cushy sinecures and selling their electorates down the river.

              The final failure of their worker's paradise in the USSR has sapped them of all energy and hope. The "placemen" at the CFR are the result of that dessication.
              And, frankly, it has never occured to me that "winning" a debate is important, or that I should be hurt when someone like Airshark or kah, among others (for whom winning a pseudo debate or declaring intellectual superiority over invisible others is obviously very important) ridicule me.

              -The Artist formerly known as King in KC

              Comment

              Working...
              X